Comparison Guide on Roofing Materials: Cost, Longevity, and Aesthetic Appeal Between Metal and Asphalt Shingles
In the world of roofing, two popular options stand out: asphalt shingles and metal shingles. Each has its own advantages and disadvantages, and understanding these differences can help homeowners and business owners make informed decisions.
Asphalt shingles, a common choice due to their wide variety of styles and relatively straightforward installation, typically last 15-20 years on average. High-end asphalt shingles can withstand damage better due to increased material bulk. However, they require more maintenance than metal shingles, including sealant repairs, granule maintenance, and vigilant debris removal.
On the other hand, metal shingles are a more durable and long-lasting alternative. Premium-grade metal roofing shingles often come with 50-year warranties or even lifetime material coverage. Metal shingles excel in needing little more than occasional inspection and cleaning to keep performing year after year. They are also more resistant to climate and environmental factors.
Metal shingles are available in various grades, with premium options having a practical lifespan exceeding 70 years, while more affordable steel and aluminum options still deliver 50+ years of reliable performance. Metal roofing is more suitable for owners focused on maximizing longevity to over 50+ years and keeping lifetime costs affordable.
When it comes to cost, asphalt roofing costs range from $80-250 per 100 square feet, while metal shingles start at $200 per square and can exceed $1000 for premium architectural grades and custom work. Consulting experts like Heather & Little is recommended for guidance on metal roofing solutions and installation needs.
For historically registered properties, seeking out specialists familiar with obtaining historically accurate metal shingles is essential for preservation legitimacy. Key historical metal roofing options include copper, tin, lead, zinc, and steel (galvanized or galvalume). Modern metal roofing systems like TimberSteel™ offer historically sympathetic alternatives with enhanced durability and easier installation.
Buildings with metal roofing consistently earn higher property appraisal value and resale value compared to identical structures featuring asphalt shingles. Proper debris clearing practices are crucial to prevent wear on asphalt shingles, while metal roofs require minimal maintenance.
In conclusion, while asphalt shingles offer a variety of styles and are relatively easy to install, metal shingles provide a more durable and long-lasting solution. Homeowners and business owners who prioritize longevity, minimal maintenance, and increased property value may find metal shingles to be the better choice. For historically registered properties, seeking out specialists familiar with obtaining historically accurate metal shingles is essential for preservation legitimacy.
Contacting Heather & Little directly online allows for reviewing project specifics like measurements, stylistic goals, and budget. Heather & Little focuses on architectural design, premium metal roofing materials, and applications for homes or businesses.
