Skip to content

"Prioritizing practicality over advocacy"

Online publication by Der Spiegel on July 14, 2025 featuring a letter by Hans Christoph Goedeking titled 'Or Does My Memory Deceive Me'

"Prioritizing practicality over ideology"
"Prioritizing practicality over ideology"

"Prioritizing practicality over advocacy"

In the heart of our city, the Kaiserstraße, a recent project saw the installation of a new bench at a cost of 264,000 euros. However, a local advocate, Sebastian Heilmann, has raised concerns about the potential opportunity lost in favour of a more sustainable and environmentally beneficial alternative: the greening of the wall.

Heilmann, the author of this article, suggests that the money spent on the bench project could have been used to plant at least four or six trees on the wall, providing a visual and climatic enhancement that far outweighs the functional benefits of the bench.

Green walls, as Heilmann points out, offer multiple benefits. They visually enhance urban environments, reduce heat islands, improve air quality, and contribute to biodiversity. These environmental advantages often justify their investment over simpler amenities such as benches, which primarily offer comfort and social value but little direct climatic improvement.

The Sustainable Kaiserstraße initiative, which emphasises innovative green design and eco-friendly solutions, underscores the significance of green wall restorations for urban climate enhancement. Green walls, by cooling and improving air quality, can reduce city temperatures by up to 10 degrees, positively impacting urban microclimate and thermal comfort for residents and visitors.

While bench projects represent investments in urban furniture that improve usability and social experience in public spaces, green walls require higher initial installation and maintenance costs, including structural support, irrigation, and ongoing care.

Considering a cost-benefit perspective, green wall restoration offers far greater benefits for visual appeal and climate regulation compared to bench projects. However, specific numeric spending values for Kaiserstraße projects are not currently available, making an exact cost comparison challenging.

Heilmann, in expressing his desire for more pragmatism and less activism from the administration, encourages a balanced approach to urban development that considers both social and environmental needs. He advocates for the greening of the wall as a practical, sustainable solution that benefits both the city's aesthetics and climate.

Readers who share Heilmann's perspective can submit their letters to the editor of the website Rundschau at redaktion@unsere Webseite. The link to submit letters to the editor of Rundschau can be found at a specific location. General notes on publication can also be found at the same location.

The suggested trees for the wall are commercially available and not gilded, making them accessible and suitable for the project.

[1] Source: [Sustainable Kaiserstraße initiative](https://www.sustainable-kaiserstraße.de/)

  1. Sebastian Heilmann, author of the article, suggests that the funds allocated for the bench project in Kaiserstraße could have been used to plant trees on the wall, offering a visual and climatic improvement that surpasses the functional benefits of the bench.
  2. According to Heilmann, green walls provide multiple environmental advantages, including visually enhancing urban spaces, reducing heat islands, improving air quality, and contributing to biodiversity, often making them a more beneficial investment over simpler amenities like benches.
  3. The Sustainable Kaiserstraße initiative emphasizes the importance of green wall restorations for urban climate enhancement, as they can lower city temperatures by up to 10 degrees and improve urban microclimate and thermal comfort for residents and visitors.

Read also:

    Latest