Comparing Costs, Eco-Friendliness, and Quality: Fireworks vs. Drone Shows? - Which one costs more, is more environmentally friendly, and offers a superior spectacle: fireworks or a drone show?
Article:
Amidst the traditional summer festivities, the debate about fireworks versus drone shows has gained momentum. With the ongoing drought and growing concerns over the environment, many events are considering alternate options - such as drone or light shows.
In Mainz, the Johannisnacht festival will forgo traditional fireworks in favor of a music-accompanied drone show. The shift, however, comes at a significantly higher cost; roughly double that of fireworks. On the other hand, "Rhein in Flammen" in Koblenz opted to add a drone show alongside their conventional fireworks display, marking the first time for such an event. The Bund for Environment and Nature Conservation (BUND) is hoping for a similar change at the Schiersteiner harbor festival in Wiesbaden due to the locale's sensitivity as it adjoins an EU bird protection area and a nature reserve.
Conversely, Frankfurt Museum Embankment Festival plans to cap off its event with a fireworks display accompanied by music. Until now, large-scale light shows have been limited to only major special events.
Due to the harsh drought and the resulting fire risk, some fireworks displays may be canceled this season, as warned by the BUND Rhineland-Palatinate. Fireworks themselves generate waste and toxic substances like perchlorate, which contribute to soil, water, and air pollution. These harmful substances are absorbed by plants, animals, and humans and remain in the environment for an extended period. The fireworks industry counters this concern, stating that the substances are water-soluble and only pose a problem for about ten minutes each year.
Drone shows carry a substantial budget requirement. Smaller shows starting at around $15,000 for 100 drones can be more affordable than traditional fireworks, whereas larger shows with thousands of drones can equal or surpass the cost of fireworks. The costs for both options can increase significantly amid the escalating expenses of stage technology, permits, and safety measures for large events.
Compared to fireworks, drones may only offer limited visual interest, as they tend to become repetitive quickly. Thus, organizers often find fireworks to be a more appealing choice for folk festivals and events with limited budgets. However, drones could potentially serve as supplements to fireworks, displaying symbols, logos, and messages in the sky.
Environmental concerns aside, drones are susceptible to wind and rain, limiting their ability to ascend effectively in less-than-ideal weather conditions. Their production is not particularly eco-friendly, either. Some argue that a combination of drones and fireworks for a multi-dimensional display offers the best of both worlds, bridging the gap between traditional pyrotechnics and modern technology, and creating a more captivating experience for spectators.
Ultimately, the exchange between old and new traditions may present new possibilities for events, making them eco-friendlier while still offering an impressive visual spectacle for audiences.
Community policy should consider the implications of drone shows and their environmental impact, especially in terms of home-and-garden lifestyles, as they grow in popularity as alternatives to fireworks.
Employment policies may need to adapt to cater to the increasing demand for individuals skilled in drone operations and shows, as the festival industry transitions towards more eco-friendly, technologically advanced displays.
